Rental cars in Long Island from $40

A trusted Expedia brand

Book a car in 3 easy steps

Find great deals

Recent car searches in Long Island, New York, United States of America from $40 per day

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Long Island
View all cars

Best rated stations in Long Island, New York, United States of America

84268 logo

Terminal A, Building 22, Queens

Average pickup time: 0-10 minutes.
9 out of 10 (51 Reviews)
Friendliness
9.4 /10
Friendliness 94%
Cleanliness
9.4 /10
Cleanliness 94%
Pickup time
9.7 /10
Pickup time 97%
Overall value
8.7 /10
Overall value 87%
5 out of 5
IvanPReviewed on Dec 18, 2018, 5:18 PM
For me is about the price. Nothing else. A car should take you from A to B. The price was good and I had a great experience with Hertz.
1 out of 5
Jtilak07Reviewed on Dec 3, 2018, 5:24 PM
Came out of airport and found the hertz shuttle without a problem. Driver was nice and drove us right over to hertz location. Went to counter to pickup my vehicle. The lady that helped me gave me my vehicle and didn’t mention anything. Just took my license and credit card. Handed me my paper work and told me the location number to find the vehicle. I walked up and was like this isn’t right. I went back into the office and spoke with another counter employee. He looked up my reservation and whatnot and he said he was puzzled as to why she DOWNGRADED my rental. He quickly fixed in and said wait outside they will pull it up in a minute for me. So we waited outside in the cold weather. After about 25 minutes they brought the vehicle up. It was wet, still dirty inside, had an odor smell on the inside. Just the worst ever experience I ever had picking a vehicle up at hertz and I’ve been renting with them for the last 9-10 years. Definitely changed my opinion on them. They should have upgraded me into another vehicle due to their employee messing up everything.
5 out of 5
o'dellReviewed on Nov 13, 2018, 9:21 AM
as LaGuardia Airport goes thru a reconstruction phase .Hertz made my rental process easy without hassle and very professional
112017 logo

350 Route 109

Average pickup time: 11-20 minutes.
8.7 out of 10 (3 Reviews)
Friendliness
7.3 /10
Friendliness 73%
Cleanliness
8 /10
Cleanliness 80%
Pickup time
10 /10
Pickup time 100%
Overall value
8.7 /10
Overall value 87%
3 out of 5
JoeReviewed on Feb 14, 2019, 7:45 PM
My experience with this supplier was ok. They certainly were not overly friendly. I did not get the exact car I reserved but did receive something comparable.
110219 logo

238 Atlantic Ave

Average pickup time: 0-10 minutes.
7.3 out of 10 (6 Reviews)
Friendliness
7.7 /10
Friendliness 77%
Cleanliness
8 /10
Cleanliness 80%
Pickup time
8 /10
Pickup time 80%
Overall value
7 /10
Overall value 70%
4 out of 5
delcolReviewed on Jul 4, 2020, 6:53 PM
No problems. Service was great. Only problem was the high price of the rental.
4 out of 5
DonnaReviewed on Dec 18, 2018, 7:56 PM
My experience with the car rental company was quick and great customer service.
3 out of 5
Ron45Reviewed on Sep 8, 2018, 2:00 PM
No problem at all with Carrentals. Hertz is the only one to blame. The do not know how to work foreign credit cards. We were delate in our road trip 3 hours, we had to wait at an insanely hot garage. I doubt I would use Hertz again. But Carrentals worked perfectly.
111735 logo

906 Union St

Average pickup time: >60 minutes.
6.3 out of 10 (13 Reviews)
Friendliness
7.5 /10
Friendliness 75%
Cleanliness
7.1 /10
Cleanliness 71%
Pickup time
7.8 /10
Pickup time 78%
Overall value
7.2 /10
Overall value 72%
5 out of 5
TrinaReviewed on Sep 17, 2020, 4:37 PM
My experience with Hertz was fantastic. The level of service provided by their team was exceptional. When I arrived they didn't have the small SUV I reserved available, due to mechanical issues, not their fault. I was moving my daughter into college in NY and the only thing they had left was a Silverado, but the idea of navigating the narrow streets of NY in a Silverado and finding parallel parking for it in Brooklyn instantly added to my stress level. It was not what I reserved. The young woman I was working with and her manager worked hard to get me into a car. They had one being serviced and was nearly complete, not too far away. The young woman drove me in her personal car to pick up the vehicle to avoid me having to wait even longer for someone to go and pick it up. I did wait quite a long time to get into the car, about 3 hours, but they made up for it by awarding me 1 day at no charge as a result of the wait time. They were incredibly kind and communicative through the process. Something that was out of their control and they did their level best to meet the reservation successfully. I would absolutely recommend Hertz, particularly this location in Park Slope.
1 out of 5
KristianReviewed on Sep 9, 2020, 5:21 PM
DO NOT RENT A CAR FROM THIS PLACE unless you like to wait and wait and wait some more. I had a reservation for 9 am and showed up at 8:50 am only to find a huge line outside their garage. It took more than an hour of standing in line outside in the sun before I was given a car. The person who took me to the car explained that the boss prioritized the platinum members so us regular people had to wait even longer in line than we should have. Now that the boss was out the employees could let the rest of us get cars too. The car I got was not the intermediate 4 door car I had booked but a huge van with 7 seats. The explanation I got was that they had only 3 cars left and if there had been 3 people in front of me in line I wouldn't have gotten a car. Are you kidding me??? It was too late for me to book somewhere else so I didn't have a choice but to accept this huge car, an hour after I was supposed to have left. Coming back was no different. I showed up at 8 am, an hour before my time was up. There was a line of cars going around the block, waiting to return the cars. This effectively blocked one lane going around the corner and I waited 40 minutes until a woman knocked on the window and said I could leave the car and come back at noon. They wouldn't charge me for that, she said. Why do I need to come back at noon, I said. She said she needed to fill out the paperwork. Why can't you do it now, I said. She didn't respond but said I was welcome to wait. A while later a guy told me to drive around the corner. There was an open parking there. The woman from before would show me where, he said. I drove up but the woman was nowhere to be seen. I found a spot to park the car anyway and saw that the woman was busy explaining to the police why they were blocking traffic around the block. Eventually she came up to my car, looked at my papers and noted the milage and gas. Apparently this is the part she couldn't do last time we spoke and if I had left I would have had to come back at noon just to watch her do it. This took her less than 20 seconds. How can you run a business like this? If you don't have enough cars you shouldn't let people book them. Overbooking, lack of information and poor customer service are the keywords here. This place is clearly mismanaged and I don't understand how Hertz can let this continue.
1 out of 5
CulpritReviewed on Aug 26, 2020, 4:45 PM
Although it's close to my house, I'll go out to the airport next time. I waited an hour in line to pick up my reserved rental. I've rented during Covid from other agencies and while you have to wait outside, you get served more quickly. The clerk who brought out the car was not wearing gloves and the car had obviously not been cleaned well. Also the back cover over the storage area was broken. Funky car overall.

Frequently asked questions

What are the major attractions in Long Island?
If your trip to Long Island is all organized but your itinerary is looking a bit empty, we can give you a few hints and tips.Outdoor adventures or hitting up the local nightlife? Whatever kind of traveler you are, CarRentals.com will help you realize your vacation dreams.
How can I get a cheap car rental in Long Island?
Here are our recommendations on how to hit the road with extra cash in your wallet:

  • Investigate as many different bargain deals as possible (we make that task completely painless!);
  • Set up an email Price Drop Alert for your next exciting vacation destination. You never know what great deals will make a pit stop in your inbox;
  • Search for both airport and non-airport pickup and drop-off office locations to ensure you’re receiving the cheapest offer in town;
  • If your dates are not set in concrete, try getting a better deal by switching up the days in your search;
  • No one likes being charged a late fee. Avoid the trouble of having to pay for an extra day by making sure your pickup and drop-off times are similar;
  • Keep more cash in your bank account. You’ll get some of the cheapest deals when you pay in advance for your rental vehicle;
  • The early bird catches the juiciest worm, along with the hottest deals! Book as soon as possible to drive off with some excellent savings.

What kind of rental car should I get for Long Island?
A rental car allows you to get around the top sights with ease in Long Island. If you’re traveling on a shoestring and want to stretch your budget, a mini or a compact is a terrific choice. These smaller cars are affordable to run and a breeze to park. If you’re traveling with the family, an SUV will give you room to move.
Should I get a luxury rental car in Long Island?
Sometimes it’s all about the journey, which makes finding the right car important. If you’re about to embark on an unforgettable road trip around Long Island, a roomy SUV could be the best solution. If you’re hoping for the best possible deal and plan on staying mostly in the city, a budget compact is a clever pick. All you need to do is choose what’s the best fit, round up the troops, and start clocking up those miles.

Car rental company addresses in Long Island

Hertz

Top rated Hertz rental locations in Long Island

1830 W Main St, Riverhead, USA
Terminal A, Building 22, Queens, New York City, USA
350 Route 109, West Babylon, USA
238 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, USA
906 Union St, Brooklyn, USA

Car Rentals in Top Destinations

Toronto Car RentalsSan Jose Car RentalsJFK John F Kennedy Intl Car RentalsIAH George Bush Intercontinental Car RentalsRSW Southwest Florida Intl Car RentalsJacksonville Car RentalsSEA Seattle Tacoma Intl Car RentalsWashington Car RentalsATL Hartsfield Jackson Atlanta Intl Car RentalsDTW Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Car RentalsPhiladelphia Car RentalsSalt Lake City Car RentalsSacramento Car RentalsCalgary Car RentalsAlbuquerque Car RentalsPIE St Petersburg Clearwater Intl Car RentalsYYZ Pearson Intl Car RentalsFLL Fort Lauderdale Hollywood Intl Car RentalsOakland Car RentalsDCA Ronald Reagan Washington National Car RentalsSMF Sacramento Intl Car RentalsSNA John Wayne Car RentalsCanada Car RentalsFlorida Car RentalsPBI Palm Beach Intl Car RentalsTucson Car RentalsDetroit Car RentalsSFO San Francisco Intl Car RentalsPSP Palm Springs Intl Car RentalsIAD Washington Dulles Intl Car RentalsCharlotte Car RentalsLGA LaGuardia Car RentalsFresno Car RentalsBuffalo Car RentalsColumbus Car RentalsEWR Liberty Intl Car RentalsIndianapolis Car RentalsBWI Baltimore Washington Intl Thurgood Marshall Car RentalsPDX Portland Intl Car RentalsMinneapolis St Paul Car RentalsNew Orleans Car RentalsAnchorage Car RentalsSAN San Diego Intl Car RentalsEl Paso Car RentalsMYR Myrtle Beach Intl Car RentalsSJC Norman Y Mineta San Jose Intl Car RentalsNashville Car RentalsMississauga Car RentalsFAT Fresno Yosemite Intl Car RentalsMilwaukee Car RentalsONT Los Angeles Ontario Intl Car RentalsMemphis Car RentalsCVG Cincinnati Northern Kentucky Intl Car RentalsSJU Luis Munoz Marin Intl Car RentalsBUR Hollywood Burbank Car RentalsMSP Minneapolis St Paul Intl Car RentalsSDQ Las Americas Intl Car Rentals