Rental cars at MacArthur Airport from $55

A trusted Expedia brand

Book a car in 3 easy steps

Find great deals

Recent car searches in MacArthur, New York - United States of America $55

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in MacArthur
View all cars

Best rated stations in Islip, NY, United States of America (ISP-MacArthur)

76725 logo

100 Arrival Avenue

Average pickup time: 11-20 minutes.
9.2 out of 10 (29 Reviews)
9.4 /10
" "Friendliness 94%
8.4 /10
" "Cleanliness 84%
Pickup time
9.5 /10
" "Pickup time 95%
Overall value
8.7 /10
" "Overall value 87%
3 out of 5
MichelleReviewed on Oct 4, 2019, 6:45 PM
I haven’t had a problem in the past using thrifty but this time was not their best service. It started off by getting a car that the wheel was making an awful sound when I left the parking lot so I turned around handed in the keys the girls said they were sorry about that and upgraded me to a different car. It was fine for a day then in the middle of the night driving home the tire pressure light came on and when I’m a few seconds I heard the tire flat. It took me a while to even find a number to call about service and by the time I did my boyfriend was able to put on the spare on. The guy on the service line was nice but pretty much said all I could do was get it back to the rental place to get a new car. Which fine but what if I was far from the rental then what? When I got there the woman that was “helping me” and I use that very loosely cause there was barely 5 words spoken to me. I was made to feel like I did something wrong the way she was not looking at me and would barely even answer a question. I was just handed the keys to the new vehicle and told the rental stayed the same. So I left I was an hour late to work cause I had to bring the car in. I brought it back told the lady about my experience and I was told well that’s her personality really. To me that is not an excuse to be treated rudely over something I did not have any control over. I will be re thinking my car rental companies in the future
4 out of 5
clami 02Reviewed on Sep 23, 2019, 7:47 PM
the pickup and drop off were easily located in the terminal and the price was reasonable. i would book through them again.
4 out of 5
DerekReviewed on Dec 6, 2018, 5:19 PM
My experience was positive with everyone connected to the company. Everyone was helpful and courteous.
3677 logo

100 Arrival Avenue

Average pickup time: 0-10 minutes.
9.2 out of 10 (12 Reviews)
9.3 /10
" "Friendliness 93%
9.5 /10
" "Cleanliness 95%
Pickup time
7.5 /10
" "Pickup time 75%
Overall value
8 /10
" "Overall value 80%
5 out of 5
NancyReviewed on Sep 1, 2019, 5:37 PM
This was much easier than I anticipated. Maybe it was the time I flew in and due to the hurricane I left earlier and returned the car a day earlier. I have been looking for the best price rental for a car Sept.24-29 at Islip airport again. I am not good at using the internet so maybe you could help me get the best price for those days. I see in my mail ads for coupons for the next time I need a rental but I don't know how to retrieve them.
5 out of 5
KatherineReviewed on Dec 29, 2018, 3:36 PM
Very easy and quick to pick up at Islip airport. Dropping off at LaGuardia airport was a long nightmare.... VERY difficult to find drop off location, had to stop and ask a stranger, then had to take two different buses to get to the airport terminal. Never again.
4 out of 5
dominickReviewed on Dec 17, 2018, 6:19 PM
even though picking up there rental was a bit confusing, the final results were good. the signs when getting to terminal at macarther airport for car rentals only state rental returns, doesn't tell you where to pick-up. sat in a office with Avis signs for 20 minutes with no one in the office, until me and another customer of there's drove around and found the terminal itself is where you pick up, not one direction to do so from booking on-line or signs when you get there, the gentlemen at the terminal who help us was very professional and apologized for our half hour run around, but he made it up with his professionalism.
35995 logo

100 Arrival Ave

Average pickup time: 0-10 minutes.
9.1 out of 10 (30 Reviews)
9.5 /10
" "Friendliness 95%
8.8 /10
" "Cleanliness 88%
Pickup time
9.5 /10
" "Pickup time 95%
Overall value
8.6 /10
" "Overall value 86%
2 out of 5
ThomasReviewed on Feb 17, 2020, 3:59 PM
Rate quoted did not ask for driver's age, once at the desk to pick up car there was a substantial up charge for an under 25 age driver.
5 out of 5
MiltonReviewed on Jan 6, 2020, 7:58 PM
My experience with car rental was great. Easy process in picking up and returning. The vehicle was in great shape, clean inside and out.
4 out of 5
IReviewed on Sep 23, 2019, 5:11 PM
When I picked up my car they didn’t have the size I reserved, I had to take a small car, which was very uncomfortable. They did take $30 off, just hoping in 2 weeks when I have to rent again they have the car I reserved

Frequently asked questions

Where is Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur)?
There’s so much to learn about Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur), but there’s no need to feel overwhelmed. Before you drive off in your rental car, let’s start with a few basics.Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur) is located 28 miles to the southeast from downtown Stamford.
What are the major attractions near Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur)?
If your trip to Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur) is all organized but your travel itinerary is a little on the empty side, we can give you a helping hand.Make your way straight from the runway to Lake Ronkonkoma. Other attractions you won’t want to miss include Smithaven Mall and Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts.
What are the best road trip destinations near Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur)?
If Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur) is your final destination, don’t waste time making your way to New York. Home to the iconic attraction, Times Square, it’s situated 47 miles away.
What kind of rental car should I get from Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur)?
With whom and where you’ll be traveling will help determine what kind of ride you opt for. If you simply need to travel from point A to B in Stamford, around 28 miles from Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur), grab an economy car. They’re ideal if you want to save money and don’t plan to spend hours in the driver’s seat. Prefer to race down the highway in search of your next big adventure? A standard car or a full-size sedan offers more comfort and room for your friends. That extra space will also prove useful if you plan to journey out to the surrounding rocky coastlines that Fairfield County is renowned for.
Should I get a luxury rental car in Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur)?
There’s loads of choice when it comes to renting a car in Islip, NY Airport (ISP-MacArthur). From luxury models to economy rides that are a snap to park, you’ll find it all here. Deciding on your perfect match depends on your budget and what activities you’ve got planned. Some road trips are just begging you to splurge on your dream ride, whereas other adventures don’t need anything more than four wheels and a gas pedal.

Car Rental Information

Airport pick-up location: MacArthur Airport
Airport code ISP
Airport city Ronkonkoma
Lowest price $55
Popular car types: SUV, Full size, Economy & Standard

Car rental company addresses in MacArthur


Top rated Enterprise rental locations in MacArthur

1911 Route 112, Medford, USA
324 E Main St, Smithtown, USA

Top rated Hertz rental locations in MacArthur

188 Medford Avenue, Patchogue, USA
2267 Middle Country Road, Centereach, USA

Top rated Avis rental locations in MacArthur

1831 Route 112 (Long Island), Medford, USA

Car Rentals in Top Destinations

Toronto Car RentalsSan Jose Car RentalsJFK John F Kennedy Intl Car RentalsIAH George Bush Intercontinental Car RentalsRSW Southwest Florida Intl Car RentalsJacksonville Car RentalsSEA Seattle Tacoma Intl Car RentalsWashington Car RentalsATL Hartsfield Jackson Atlanta Intl Car RentalsDTW Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Car RentalsPhiladelphia Car RentalsSalt Lake City Car RentalsSacramento Car RentalsCalgary Car RentalsAlbuquerque Car RentalsPIE St Petersburg Clearwater Intl Car RentalsYYZ Pearson Intl Car RentalsFLL Fort Lauderdale Hollywood Intl Car RentalsOakland Car RentalsDCA Ronald Reagan Washington National Car RentalsSMF Sacramento Intl Car RentalsSNA John Wayne Car RentalsCanada Car RentalsFlorida Car RentalsPBI Palm Beach Intl Car RentalsTucson Car RentalsDetroit Car RentalsSFO San Francisco Intl Car RentalsPSP Palm Springs Intl Car RentalsIAD Washington Dulles Intl Car RentalsCharlotte Car RentalsLGA LaGuardia Car RentalsFresno Car RentalsBuffalo Car RentalsColumbus Car RentalsEWR Liberty Intl Car RentalsIndianapolis Car RentalsBWI Baltimore Washington Intl Thurgood Marshall Car RentalsPDX Portland Intl Car RentalsMinneapolis St Paul Car RentalsNew Orleans Car RentalsAnchorage Car RentalsSAN San Diego Intl Car RentalsEl Paso Car RentalsMYR Myrtle Beach Intl Car RentalsSJC Norman Y Mineta San Jose Intl Car RentalsNashville Car RentalsMississauga Car RentalsFAT Fresno Yosemite Intl Car RentalsMilwaukee Car RentalsONT Los Angeles Ontario Intl Car RentalsMemphis Car RentalsCVG Cincinnati Northern Kentucky Intl Car RentalsSJU Luis Munoz Marin Intl Car RentalsBUR Hollywood Burbank Car RentalsMSP Minneapolis St Paul Intl Car RentalsSDQ Las Americas Intl Car Rentals