$124 Cheap Car Rental in Shelter Island, NY

Pick-up and drop-off

Same as pick-up

Pick-up time

Drop-off time

Driver under 30 or over 70 years old

Young or senior drivers may be required to pay an additional fee.

Include AARP member rates

Membership is required and verified at pick-up.

I have a discount code

Preferred brand

A trusted Expedia brand

Book a car in 3 easy steps

Find great deals

Recent car searches in Shelter Island, New York - United States of America $124

* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices.

Economy Special

Managers Special

4 people
Unlimited mileage

New York, New York, USA

$86

$124 total

found 1 day ago

Compact

Ford Focus

5 people
Unlimited mileage

New York, New York, USA

$88

$126 total

found 1 day ago

Midsize

Kia K4

5 people
Unlimited mileage

New York, New York, USA

$90

$129 total

found 1 day ago

Fullsize

Nissan Altima

5 people
Unlimited mileage

New York, New York, USA

$92

$132 total

found 1 day ago

Standard

Volkswagen Jetta

5 people
Unlimited mileage

New York City, New York, USA

$104

$147 total

found 1 day ago

Mini Van

Chrysler Pacifica

7 people
Unlimited mileage

New York City, New York, USA

$110

$155 total

found 1 day ago

Premium SUV

Ford Expedition Max

7 people
Unlimited mileage

New York City, New York, USA

$234

$322 total

found 1 day ago

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Shelter Island

View all cars

Car Rental Information

City pick-up location	Shelter Island
Lowest price	$124
Popular car types:	SUV, Full size, Economy & Standard

Popular Destinations

Cars