$37 Cheap Car Rental in Montauk, NY

A trusted Expedia brand

Book a car in 3 easy steps

Find great deals

Recent car searches in Montauk, New York - United States of America $37

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all car rentals in Montauk
View all cars

Frequently asked questions

Where is Montauk?
Getting to know Montauk will be a breeze once you have your own rental car. But before you land in a completely new place, it’s always handy to know some basic info about the area.This town sits 25 miles to the south of Pawcatuck, and 304 miles northeast of Washington, the nation’s capital.If you’re traveling with the young ones and they’re tired of road trip bingo, why not give them a quick quiz to see if they can tell you what the population of this part of Town of East Hampton is? (In case you’re unsure yourself, it’s 3,300!)
What are the major attractions in Montauk?
If your trip to Montauk is all locked in but your itinerary is a little on the empty side, we can give you a helping hand.You simply can’t spend time in this town without heading to Montauk Point Lighthouse. This attraction lures countless travelers every year. Time to find out just what makes it so popular.There’s nothing like exploring new places. While you’re here, Montauk Point and Ditch Plains Beach should be among them. Another popular attraction to consider is Hither Hills State Park.
How can I get a cheap car rental in Montauk?
Below we’ve listed our top tips and tricks to help you save:

  • Our terrific filter feature is going to become your new best buddy. Sift through the cheapest bargains from all of the top car rental companies quickly and easily;
  • Register for our Price Drop Alert email service and stay up to date when prices become cheaper for your destination;
  • Search for both airport and non-airport pickup and drop-off locations to be sure you’re receiving the cheapest price around;
  • You can sometimes save a few dollars if your plans are flexible. Compare different days and dates and find out what savings you can score;
  • Pickup and drop-off times usually need to be similar (e.g, both 11 a.m.) or you could be required to pay for an entire extra day;
  • Some rental outlets offer big incentives to pay upfront, so make sure you keep your eyes peeled for these penny-pinching deals;
  • Don’t let the deal you’ve been searching for slip through your grasp. Book as soon as you can and drive away with your ideal ride.

What kind of rental car should I get for Montauk?
Whether you’re on the road on your own or with the whole gang, we have the perfect set of wheels for you in Montauk. If you want something small, why not consider a mini or compact? These nifty cars are easy to drive and cheap on gas. Excited to check out the surrounding areas? An SUV might just be the ticket. If you want to go all out on your getaway, turn some heads with a feature-packed premium car.
Should I get a luxury rental car in Montauk?
There’s loads of choice when it comes to rental cars in Montauk. From SUVs with trunk space galore to easy-to-park compacts, you’ll find it all here. Choosing your perfect match depends on how much you want to spend and what activities you’ve got planned. Some road trips are just begging you to splurge on your dream ride, whereas other adventures don’t need anything more than four wheels and a gas pedal. The choice is yours.

Car Rental Information

City pick-up location
Lowest price
Popular car types:
SUV, Full size, Economy & Standard