Car Rentals print logo
person_add face menu
Car Rentals print logo
person_add face menu

Cheap car rentals in Shelter Island, New York

Search for a car rental

Cheap car rentals in Shelter Island, New York

check_circle Free cancellation on most bookings

car image placeholder
  • Trusted by 8 million customers and counting
  • Special low rates available here
  • Huge selection of cars, locations, companies
  • Rent a car coupons & deals
  • Easy searching & booking.
Rent a car in 60 seconds

Car rentals in Shelter Island: All you need to know

You need a great automobile to get around Shelter Island whether you're traveling for a business trip or a vacation. Check out the famous sites around the area and pull up in front of the popular restaurants in Shelter Island. CarRentals.com has answered the most popular questions about car rentals in Shelter Island. Find out the dos and don'ts of booking a rental car.

Where do I find a bargain car rental in Shelter Island?

We always try to get you the best deal. However, there are a more ways to increase your savings. Make sure to:

  • Compare the prices of vehicles
  • Try to avoid airport pick-ups and drop-offs, which typically cost more
  • Know ahead of time the amount of fuel/mileage you may use
  • Search and book in advance

Just following even a few of these tips can help you save big on your Shelter Island rental car.

What rental companies have agencies in Shelter Island?

From global names like Ace and Enterprise to budget-friendly brands like Thrifty and Budget, CarRentals.com has some of the best brands in the business. Scan through the reviews to get an idea of which one meets your needs.

What types and makes of rental cars are on offer in Shelter Island?

That depends on how many people you are traveling with and what you'll be doing when you visit Shelter Island. If you're having trouble deciding, make sure to read over our chart below. We've compared the most popular categories for you:

Car TypeBest forCategory Includes
Full Size SUVTo take on any kind of terrain and enjoy great viewsFord Explorer, Hyundai Santa Fe, or similar
Full SizeIf you plan on doing a lot of touring and want a comfortable rideInfiniti Q50, Ford Fusion, or similar
Economy or Compact CarEasy to park and have great miles per gallonChevrolet Spark, Vauxhall Corsa, or similar

What's the age requirement to rent a car in Shelter Island?

Normally, the age limit for car rentals in Shelter Island is 21. However, you may find that there is an added charge if you are under the age of 25 or for higher category vehicles in particular. Go over the terms to find what the exact charge is before you book your car.

Will I need insurance to get a car rental in Shelter Island?

When driving in Shelter Island or the rest of the U.S.A., you'll need insurance. Almost every supplier needs proof of insurance before you rent a car. The majority of countries require driver's insurance. You might be able to buy additional insurance through the rental car dealer for your trip, if you are concerned your insurance won't cover you while traveling through the U.S.A.. Otherwise, as a United States citizen, you can also purchase Collision Damage Coverage through CarRentals.com during checkout.

Many major card issuers, like American Express or MasterCard, give some insurance on your rental, however, there are usually restrictions. For instance, they may not cover your rental car if you reserve a luxury or larger vehicle. Check the rental car company's policy before you decide.

What is the difference between all the fuel policies?

Most suppliers give you a choice of fuel policies. Here is a list of the typical policies.

You will need to search for a gas station close to your rental car supplier
Policy TypePolicy DescriptionAdvantagesDisadvantages
Full to FullThe tank will be full when you collect your car. Use as much gas as you like and then refill the tank when you drop the vehicle off. Just make sure to refill the tank before you return the car to avoid a refueling costYou only need to replace the fuel you used. Used a quarter of a tank? Simply fill it back up to full. You won't be paying for any gas you didn't use. You can fill up at any station you want and you'll only pay service fees if you don't fill up the tank
Full to empty (pre-paid)You'll pick up the car with a full tank and return the car with an empty tank. Ask the supplier to see if they'll refund you for any unused fuelYou won't need to find a fuel station near your rental drop-off locationThe supplier usually charges a higher rate for the fuel than a local gas station
Empty to emptyYou will not have a full tank of fuel when you collect your vehicle, and you don't have to refill the gas when you drop it back offYou refill your tank yourself, so you won't pay more than local pump pricesYou'll have to fill up before you go on a long trip

What fuel policy should I get?

Many suppliers offer a variety of fuel policies. However, the stand-out winner is usually full-to-full. You simply bring the car back with the same amount of fuel you got it with. .

Should I get unlimited miles when I rent a car in Shelter Island?

Unlimited miles is a good choice if you decide to do a little sightseeing or visit several customers all over Shelter Island. You can cruise as much as you want without incurring additional charges. Make sure to read your rental agreement to discover if there are any limitations.

Before you drive off

Make sure you go over a few things before you leave the rental lot. It's important to:

  • Walk around your vehicle and make sure there is no damage or scrapes. If so, write it down on the paperwork
  • Make you have a properly inflated spare tire, lug wrench, and jack in the trunk
  • Familiarize yourself with the car. Adjust the mirrors and seats to your liking, and figure out how to turn on the lights and wipers
  • Figure out how to work the entertainment and GPS (if available). You don't want any unneeded distractions in a new city

Book your Shelter Island car rental today

Maybe you're traveling with your partner and kids, or carpooling with co-workers to and from the hotel to the conference center. Maybe you're traveling solo. CarRentals.com has the ideal vehicle that can fit your requirements and not deplete your travel fund.