close
NL flag Would you like to use our Dutch website?
We've noticed that you are visiting a version of our website that doesn't match your current location. Using our local website helps ensure you get the most relevant prices and supply.
No, continue to German website
close
DE flag Would you like to use our German website?
We've noticed that you are visiting a version of our website that doesn't match your current location. Using our local website helps ensure you get the most relevant prices and supply.
No, continue to Dutch website
Car Rentals print logo
person_add face menu
Car Rentals print logo
person_add face menu

Cheap Car Rentals in Lancaster NY

Search for a car rental

Cheap Car Rentals in Lancaster NY

check_circle Free cancellation on most bookings

car image placeholder
  • Trusted by 7 million customers and counting
  • Special low rates available here
  • Huge selection of cars, locations, companies
  • Rent a car coupons & deals
  • Easy searching & booking.
Rent a car in 60 seconds

Lancaster Car Rental Reviews

Car rental rating: 4.47 out of 5 with 15 ratings

National

"Very good experience!"

(Reviewed on September 01, 2015 )

Budget

"My representative's service was outstanding, and everything was simply great with my car rental!"

(Reviewed on August 28, 2015 )


Alamo

"I tried Alamo again after my excellent experience with Anthony in NYC. Buffalo staff was equally efficient and friendly."

(Reviewed on August 17, 2015 )

Alamo

"I had exceptional service and the representative was very patient with me. I'm grateful that I used CarRentals.com to rent my vehicle. The customer service was excellent and my vehicle was upgraded. The Chrysler 200 ran sm..." Read more

(Reviewed on July 30, 2015 )


Alamo

"The complete rental was great, from pick-up to return. Alamo has always given me great service for many years."

(Reviewed on January 23, 2015 )

ACE

"Price was great. Car was great. Staff excellent. No problems."

(Reviewed on January 15, 2015 )


Budget

"Overall yet another very good experience with Budget. Thank you, Budget."

(Reviewed on August 24, 2014 )

Alamo

"Great Service - Car did not have enough space for luggage ( was advertized for 5 pieces) but accommodated 4 and had to put a seat down for the 5th. Nonetheless - nice SUV so that was OK."

(Reviewed on August 05, 2014 )


Alamo

"I always use CarRentals.com for cars. Best site, very easy to use with no problems. Cars are always available and I can rely on the site for a great value"

(Reviewed on June 09, 2014 )

Alamo

"Loved the vehicle that I received and was very satisfied."

(Reviewed on April 23, 2014 )


Hertz

"Requested and received a Nissan Altima. The best driving experience ever. Car was beyond comfortable to drive. Logged 3310 miles and NO fatigue, was a great surprise. Rick at Orchard Park counter was superior in customer s..." Read more

(Reviewed on March 07, 2014 )

Enterprise

"Excellent experience"

(Reviewed on February 17, 2014 )


Enterprise

"Excellent service. Free XM radio."

(Reviewed on February 17, 2014 )

Enterprise

"Excellent service. Clean, newer car.."

(Reviewed on February 17, 2014 )


Please be aware that some of these reviews may have been translated automatically into English.

Car rentals in Lancaster: What you need to know

Buffalo, New York, is full of fascinating neighborhoods like Lancaster. It's in communities such as these where you can get a true sense for a city like Buffalo. But once you're done exploring all the great shops and restaurants in Lancaster, you'll want some wheels to discover everything that Buffalo offers.

Riding the bus is an inexpensive method to get around Lancaster and the nearby neighborhoods, but then you have to follow a strict schedule and make sure you have exact change. Taxis and rideshares can be more convenient, but the costs can add up. Moreover, you may not be able to get one when you need a ride. A Lancaster car rental is the best method, so you can see this great neighborhood and other areas of Buffalo on your vacation. Read below to learn all that you want about renting a car in Lancaster.

Frequently asked questions

What's the best way to get an inexpensive car rental in Lancaster?

Seeking the best rates on a car rental? You're in the right spot. To get the most savings on your trip to Lancaster you can do a few things:

  • Compare the prices of vehicles
  • Try to avoid airport pick-ups or drop-offs, which usually are more expensive
  • Know ahead of time how much fuel/mileage you may use
  • Search and reserve as far in advance as you can

Make sure you read the supplier's policy so you can determine the full cost before you book.

What kind of rental car should I get in Lancaster?

With a variety of types of vehicles to select from, it could be difficult to decide which type is ideal for your vacation. However, keep in mind your needs and how many people you are riding with. Look at the table below to help you reserve the best automobile for your visit.

Car TypeBest forCategory includes
Luxury or Premium classWhen you really want to go all out on your vacation to LancasterInfiniti Q50, Chrysler 300, or similar
SUV or MinivanFamily vacations where you need the extra roomJeep Grand Cherokee, Nissan Quest, or similar
Economy or Compact CarCouple or two friends who plan on doing some sightseeingChevrolet Spark, Vauxhall Corsa, or similar

How old do I have to be to rent a car in Lancaster?

In most places, you can rent a vehicle in Buffalo if you are at least 21. Please note most car rental companies will charge an added fee if you are younger than 25. Make sure to review the supplier's policy to find out if there is an additional cost before you book.

Do I need insurance when I rent a car?

You are required to have insurance before you rent in United States of America. It may possible to buy additional insurance through the supplier, if you know your insurance won't cover your rental during your trip.

Many of the major credit card issuers (Visa, MasterCard, American Express and Discover) generally offer coverage. However, many have prohibitions, such as not completely covering larger vehicles, like trucks or SUVs. It is best to call your credit card company and find out what kind of coverage is offered before you travel to Buffalo. Additionally, as a United States citizen, you can also book Collision Damage Coverage through CarRentals.com at checkout.

Am I required to fill my tank before I return my rental car back?

Most rental car suppliers provide you a full tank of gas. We suggest bringing your car back with the same amount as you received it. To avoid any added expenses, you should find a filling station before you return the car to the supplier.

Do most companies offer one-way rentals in Lancaster?

A lot of rental car suppliers offer one-way rentals. Depending on your travel plans, you may find it simpler to drop off your car at another location. However, there is usually an extra fee for one-way rentals. Be sure to go through the provider's policy to know the total cost.

Why should I get unlimited miles?

The majority of suppliers will offer unlimited miles, but you need to make sure it is part of the package that you are purchasing. It's useful to know how much you want to drive and plan your trips ahead of time. Although most rental car companies offer unlimited mileage, if it isn't part of your rental agreement those miles can pile up and so can the extra cost. You may need to get unlimited miles if you are hitting the open road to find out what else Buffalo or even New York has to offer.

Are there any road trips I should take from Lancaster?

Once you've checked out Lancaster, you'll be happy that you have your own set of wheels available. There are some worthwhile stops around Buffalo that are just a drive away. There is a lot of history in and around places like Lancaster. You'll find 9 historical sites and landmarks in nearby Buffalo. If you're a history buff, then you can't miss places like:

  • Buffalo and Erie County Historical Society on 25 Nottingham Ct. in Buffalo
  • EDWARD M. COTTER (fireboat) located at Jct. of Michigan and Ohio Sts. on the Buffalo River
  • Prudential Building found at Church and Pearl Sts.
  • Richardson Olmsted Complex at 400 Forest Ave. in Buffalo

New York has lots of things to do for tourist and locals alike. You may just have to get into your rental car and discover what is else is around the area.

Your Lancaster, Buffalo Ride is waiting

You won't have to worry about coordinating your trip to public transportation schedules. Once you've reserved a rental car in Lancaster, Buffalo from us, you can cruise around the neighborhood and the rest of Buffalo easily. Browse our selection of cars from some of the top-rated rental car agencies in the nation and choose the ideal auto for your Lancaster adventure!